
A LOOK BACK AT THE LAST NINE POSTS
The last nine posts talk about particular metaphors as members of larger, like-minded groups — “loophole” as a Boundary metaphor, for example. Botanists and zoologists know all about the benefits of classification. In the humanities, we favor the “free spirit” and resist using “labels.”
As it happens, “labeling” is a metaphor that benefits from being labelled.
Logically it belongs in the Family Resemblance category. A focus on traits in common and connections (parent-child, siblings) ought to yield organic rather than “cut and dried” connotations. Yet “labeling” is Dracula, sucking blood out of Truth and Beauty.
What happened? Discovering that as a question is a benefit of classification.
Another is: opening our eyes to the ABCs of perception, thought, and speech. A caveman’s ideas about a river would differ from our own, but they would be comprehensible. We have the same eyes and ears and live under the same Sky.
Finding pictures in the stars is as old as the oldest folktales. And though September 11, 2001 comes to mind when we hear “connect the dots,” the need for vigilance against surprise attack would be perfectly understandable to our ur-interlocuter.
Some of the labels used in these posts overlap: Polarization is more than cozily close to Balance. The Boundary category is akin to the Wall mentioned in the Transparency post, as is the Merely Surface category.
Labels are not set in stone. Take what’s useful, and invent new labels — as we have done since Adam.
(In Genesis 2:19, God brings each kind of animal to Adam, and Adam gives each kind a name. Since then, a sheep has been the human idea of a sheep. A sheep’s view would likely differ.)
Note: “Labeling” became a bad thing around 1850 (OED), when it was used to mean generalizing in a way that oversimplifies — a “foolish and wicked” practice when talking about individuals and their beliefs. Political parties by that time had become a parliamentary institution.
Illustration: Karl Stull
[2026]
Back to top








